Focus

Court orders return of 172 'Pride Collection' watches to the Swatch Group

The court also allowed an application by the applicant to quash the seizure notice on the grounds that the seizure was made without a warrant and was invalid.

25 Nov 2024 11:18am
Swatch Malaysia's controversial watch collection - Photo: SWATCH MALAYSIA
Swatch Malaysia's controversial watch collection - Photo: SWATCH MALAYSIA

KUALA LUMPUR - The High Court here today ordered 172 'Pride Collection' watches seized by the Home Ministry (KDN) last year to be returned to the watch importer and seller, The Swatch Group (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd.

Judge Datuk Amarjeet Singh made the decision after allowing a judicial review application filed by The Swatch Group (Malaysia) as the applicant against the secretary-general of the Home Ministry, the secretary of the Home Ministry Enforcement Division, the Home Minister and the Malaysian Government as the first to fourth respondents.

Amarjeet said the court also allowed an application by the applicant to quash the seizure notice on the grounds that the seizure was made without a warrant and was invalid.

"Therefore, the court orders that the 172 watches be returned to the applicant within 14 days starting today. If there is damage to the watches, the applicant can claim compensation," said the judge.

In today's proceedings, lawyer Nizam Bashir represented the applicant while federal counsel Mohammad Sallehuddin Md Ali represented all the respondents.

On June 24, 2023, The Swatch Group (Malaysia) filed a judicial review application to challenge KDN's action to seize 172 watches including the 'Pride Collection' series which were allegedly associated with the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community.

In the application, the applicant said the seizure of all the watches in question was unlawful because the items were not a 'publication' which could be prohibited under the Printing Presses and Publications Act 1984.

According to the company, the watch from the 2023 design is one of the six colours of the rainbow and is only visible on a small part of the watch's bezel and does not promote any sexual symptoms.

Related Articles:

On May 13 and 14, 2023, KDN raided 11 Swatch brand watch boutiques in several states and seized a rainbow-themed collection which was allegedly associated with LGBT. - BERNAMA

Court
watch
Pride Collection
KDN
The Swatch Group
judicial review
Swatch Group
Malaysia
Home Ministry
LGBT
More Like This
Abdul Rahman
Abdul Rahman
National SSPA: Avoid excessive, unnecessary loans following salary increase - Cuepacs
"If you really want to do it, it should only be for purposes that will make a profit in the future such as housing loans or children's education."
A recent tragedy claimed seven lives at Kilometer 204 of the North-South Highway heading north, near the Ayer Keroh Rest and Treatment area, Melaka. Bernama FILE PIX
A recent tragedy claimed seven lives at Kilometer 204 of the North-South Highway heading north, near the Ayer Keroh Rest and Treatment area, Melaka. Bernama FILE PIX
National Strict enforcement, heavy fines against heavy vehicles failing to comply with safety standards - Niosh
The use of advanced monitoring technology such as Tyre Pressure Monitoring Systems (TPMS) and telematics should also be mandatory for all heavy vehicles so that mechanical problems are detected directly.
The Taiping High Court has awarded RM1.8 million in damages to a former security guard who sustained a brain injury due to medical negligence during treatment following a motorcycle accident in 2016.
The Taiping High Court has awarded RM1.8 million in damages to a former security guard who sustained a brain injury due to medical negligence during treatment following a motorcycle accident in 2016.
National Court awards RM1.8 million to ex-security guard over medical negligence
Judge Noor Ruwena Md Nurdin found that the plaintiff P. Thinnagaran, 28, had proved his claims on a balance of probabilities and allowed most of his claims against the defendants.
An Indonesian woman has applied for leave from the Federal Court to appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision which dismissed her appeal seeking a court declaration that her second son is a Malaysian citizen.
An Indonesian woman has applied for leave from the Federal Court to appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision which dismissed her appeal seeking a court declaration that her second son is a Malaysian citizen.
National Son's citizenship: Indonesian woman seeking leave to appeal at Federal Court
The woman, in her 40s, filed the notice of motion, obtained by the media today, in the Federal Court last Dec 23, naming the Director General of the NRD and the Malaysian Government as respondents.